Ice fishing boots are at the bottom of many an ice angler’s list of necessities for a day’s fishing on a frozen waterway. But the only lowermost portion these provisions should be located, however, is the bottommost part of your body.

Keeping your feet warm out on the ice ensures you have an enjoyable day. While choosing the best ice fishing boots for you may seem like a simple imposition, there’s more to it than where the lugged sole meets the frozen water. After all, misery loves cold-footed company. The moment your feet get chilled, it’s too late – your entire body follows suit.

Use this guide to find the best ice fishing boots for you so you can concentrate on what counts: catching fish.

Things to Consider Before Buying Ice Fishing Boots

There’s much to ponder when picking the best ice-fishing boots, not only to give you the most bang for your Benjamins, but more so allow you to have the most comfortable, fun day while ice fishing.

Duration

How much of the day do you spend on the ice is one factor. Are you the type of angler that stays out from sunup ‘til sundown? Perhaps you only spend a couple hours holding your ice fishing rod during an average outing. The longer you tend to stay out, the more insulation you’ll want.

Temperature

Don’t overlook the average ambient air temperatures where you ice fish most. In the southern most regions of the ice fishing belt it may rarely get below the freezing mark, let alone to zero. The further north you go, the colder; to the point when it hits zero it feels kind of balmy.

Snow and Slush

The depth of normal snowpack plays a huge roll, as well. Some areas may see thigh-deep snow, where others a wisp blowing across the lake seems like a lot. And the thicker the snow on a frozen waterway the more it pushes the ice down into the lake. If this occurs, water seeps through it, creating slush between the layers.

Transportation

How you get to your fishing location is a factor, too. If you hoof it on foot, flexible, lighter-weight boots are in order. If riding on a quad, side-by-side or snowmobile, heavier boots may be just the ticket. When driving a manual-shift rig, you’ll want ice-fishing boots with reinforcement in key locations.

Best Ice Fishing Boot: Korkers POLAR VORTEX 1200

Korkers POLAR VORTEX 1200 

Key Features

• Sizes: 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14
• Weight: 4 pounds, 4 ounces (size 9)
• Color: Black/silver
• Height: 11 inches

Why It Made the Cut

The POLAR VORTEX 1200 is a very warm, waterproof, and versatile boot that is light in weight. It is extremely comfortable when walking and sitting still; easy to use with manual-shift quads, and tucks easily into a snowmobile’s footrest.

Pros

• Easy on/off
• Easiest lacing adjustments
• Interchangeable soles

Cons

• Shorter than some boots

The first thing that stands out with Korkers POLAR VORTEX 1200, the best ice fishing boots is the Boa M4 Fit System that replaces laces. This allows for fast on and off, as well a custom fit that adjusts for the thickness of socks you have on every time you use them. Spin the ratchet knob and the boot tightens evenly; pop the knob out and it loosens up quickly.

Another unique feature is the interchangeable soles. The POLAR VORTEX 1200 ships with a set of SnowTrac rubber lug and a pair of IceTrac studded-rubber lug soles. The latter is fitted with 32 carbide studs per sole for plenty of bite on the ice. Changing out the cleated sole for the rubber lug keeps vehicle floor mats and home entranceways free from damage.

There’s 1200g of 3M Thinsulate insulation, as well an aerogel frost barrier footbed underneath for keeping keep feet warm while sitting still. Yet, they won’t overheat your feet when walking.

Best for Extreme Cold: Baffin GUIDE PRO II

Baffin GUIDE PRO II 

Key Features

• Sizes: 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14
• Weight: 8 pounds, 5 ounces (size 10)
• Color: Red/black
• Height: 17 inches

Why It Made the Cut

Baffin’s GUIDE PRO II has been tested and proven in the extremes of the North and South Poles. Tall, and tremendously insulated with built-in gaiter to keep snow out and calves warm.

Pros

• Nearly knee high
• Flexible upper materials
• Breathable

Cons

• Pricey

The Baffin GUIDE PRO II’s modern-day waterproofing technology repels water, yet it remains breathable. This keeps feet and calves dry from water splash when using a power auger or when stomping through deep snow. It also allows any perspiration to escape.

The outsole of this boot is made of Polar Rubber, which stays pliable at subzero temperatures for greater grip. The B-Tek insulation is form fitting to the foot, to capitalize on heat retention and foot comfort. There’s even a reinforced-steel 3-pin toe appendage for utilizing cross-country skis when trudging through the bush when getting back to remote lakes.

Best for Women: Muck Boot Company Arctic Ice Arctic Grip A.T. Mid

Muck Boot Company Arctic Ice Arctic Grip A.T. Mid 

Key Features

• Sizes: 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11
• Weight: 2 pounds (size 8)
• Color: Black/pink accents
• Calf circumference: 15 inches

Why it made the cut

Muck Boot Company’s Arctic Ice with Arctic Grip A.T. is sized and shaped to create the right fit for a woman’s foot. These ice fishing boots are versatile and work well for other winter recreation, such as snowshoeing and small game hunting.  

Pros

• Easy walking
• Flexible materials
• 100% waterproof

Cons

• No removable liner
• Might be tight for those with large calves

A bioDEWIX footbed insert top cover in the Arctic Ice Arctic Grip A.T. Mid helps manage moisture due to condensation and sweat, which can cool off feet just as easily as easily as water entering the boot. This also helps with odor control when the day is done. 

This boot’s grip on slippery surfaces is better than the average winter footwear due to its Vibram Artic Grip A.T. sole. (Note: Ice cleats always recommended when ice fishing.) The inner lining is soft and lightweight, yet its insulation value is rated down to -40˚ Fahrenheit. The upper boot fits snug to the shin to keep water and snow out. This could hinder the tucking in of outerwear, however.

Best for Deep Snow/Slush: Clam Sub-Zero X Boot

Clam Sub-Zero X Boot 

Key Features

• Sizes: 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14
• Weight: 4 pounds, 4 ounces (size 10)
• Color: Black/charcoal

Why It Made the Cut

The wader-like construction of Clam’s Sub-Zero X Boot means that water cannot penetrate under any circumstance. They are very light weight for a vulcanized rubber, well-insulated boot.

Pros

• Seamless construction
• No laces
• Heal kick tab eases removal

Cons

• Some condensation may occur

Even if damp, wool retains heat. The removable wool liners in Clam’s Sub-Zero X boots make drying out perspiration—inevitable after a full day on the ice—very easy.

Tighten the drawstring at the top and the material keeps snow out and helps keep body heat in. This is a great boot for anglers sitting in portable shanties with no floor, or for those who hop hole to hole throughout the day. These are one of the better boots for late-season ice fishing, when shoreline snows start to melt and slush accumulates on the ice.   

Best on a Budget: Sorel Blizzard XT Boot

Sorel Blizzard XT Boot 

Key Features

• Sizes: 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15
• Weight: 1 pound, 13.6 ounces (size 10)
• Color: Black
• Height: 15.25 inches

Why It Made the Cut

Sorel’s Blizzard XT boots are a good value for the money. They offer respectable performance for quick trips on the ice after work or a few hours on the weekend.

Pros

• Good in deep snow
• Very little lacing
• Inexpensive compared to others

Cons

• Laces not waterproof
• Lower insulation value compared to others

While it’s difficult to find a boot in this price range that’s waterproof, the Blizzard XT’s synthetic upper repels H2O very well with its PU coating.

The inner liner—made with 9mm of omni-heat reflective recycled felt—is removable for quick drying of condensation. The midsole is a 2.5 mm bonded felt frost plug to keep the cold from creeping up from underneath. The boot’s top can be held snugged to your shin with its drawstring and barrel-lock closure This is good a boot for folks on a tight budget who walk a lot while ice fishing.

Methodology

After spending the last 50-something years in the snowbelt of Lower Michigan, I’ve seen the technology used to keep your tootsies toasty transform tremendously. As a kid, keeping one’s feet dry meant wrapping them in Wonder Bread bags after donning socks, then sliding them into whatever winter boot was on sale at the local five & dime that year. Later on, fishing trips on a frozen lake meant donning moon boots (you kids can Google that one up). These were more of a sponge in the shape of footwear and absorbed every ounce of moisture they could muster.

A lot has changed since those days. Subsequently, I’ve spent countless hours on hard ice, in snow on the ice, in slush on the ice, as well in temperatures from just barely freezing to 40-below zero. The following is what I delved into when critiquing the best ice-fishing boots:

• Insulation: It’s not just the amount that counts, but where it’s located in the boot. What’s between your feet and the soles is equally, if not more so, as important as the sides and top.
• Ease of putting them on and taking them off: Dressing for an ice fishing excursion is about as close to preparing for a mission to the Moon as most of us will ever get. By the time you get to your boots, you may be starting to sweat, which is not ideal. Struggling to put on a pair of boots is the last thing you want to do, as well. And taking them off without the help of someone else is just as important.
• Durability: No wants to buy a new pair of ice fishing boots every year. The construction and longevity of the footwear was a top consideration, too.
• Comfort: Warm feet doesn’t necessarily mean comfortable feet. Thoughts on high-quality insoles, weight of the boot and potential for chafing against the calf made the list, in addition.